Posts tagged Journalism
Time to ditch the press release?
Oct 7th
Fixing the newspapers. Photo (cc) Evil Erin.
At the National Astronomy Meeting in 2004 I listened to Dr David Whitehouse, who I think was then Science Editor at the BBC, give advice about feeding science stories to the media. He made quite a few points, but there are three I remember.
- Don’t push a story on the grounds it’s the biggest / oldest / shiniest / crumbliest etc. thing found. It’s a cliché and it’s dull.
- Don’t waste people’s time with the formula for ‘x’ where x is anything which really shouldn’t have a formula.
- Don’t use press releases.
At the time he really didn’t convince me. The biggest, oldest and so on remains a staple news item. Likewise Cliff Arnall has shown you can make money from nonsense formulae. What really undermined him though was the newsroom run by the RAS at the meeting. I could wander in there and see the press releases. The next day I could see the same stories, often with little editing, in the national press. If he were to give the same talk today he might find it even harder. I can go to Eurekalert and pick up a sentence from any press release. If More >
If Futurity is the answer, then I don’t understand the question
Sep 20th
I’d like to blog about the Drayson / Goldacre debate before the topic gets too cold, but before I do I thought I’d mention Futurity. It’s interesting because it’s supposedly, an attempt to address a decline in science journalism. “In an increasingly complex world, the public needs access to clear, reliable research news. Futurity does the work of gathering that news,” says the about page of the site. That’s fascinating because, if they’re right, I’ve completely misunderstood what science journalism means.
Here’s an example. First up, a press release from the University of Michigan, Researchers find gene that protects high-fat-diet mice from obesity, which starts like this:
U-M researchers have identified a gene that acts as a master switch to control obesity in mice. When the switch is turned off, even high-fat-diet mice remain thin.
Deleting the gene, called IKKE, also appears to protect mice against conditions that, in humans, lead to Type 2 diabetes, which is associated with obesity and is on the rise among Americans, including children and adolescents.
Next there’s the press release on the publicly accessible Eurekalert, U-M researchers find gene that protects high-fat-diet mice from obesity. That reads:
University of More >
Blogging and the English Law
May 31st
First a disclaimer: My legal qualifications go as far as an A-Level I did at nightclass.
Nonetheless I’ve been reading a few posts recently on English law by other bloggers and they all seem to be making the same mistake. The bloggers are intelligent, fair and reasonable and the make the assumption that English law would be too. So I’m throwing up some points for discussion, most of it applies to bloggers around the world, but there are one or two stings for bloggers based in England and Wales.
Tip One: Be a multi-millionaireThis is useful in any legal system, but especially in England when you realise where the law comes from. We don’t have a 20th century or 19th century legal system in the UK. It’s a multi-layered cake of cases which has been built up over the centuries. Old laws remain in effect because they’re often useful. For example until a few years ago the legal definition of murder in England dated from Lord Coke’s ruling in 1597.
Murder is when a man of sound memory, and of the age of discretion, unlawfully killeth within any county of More >
